Istanbul Foundation for Science and Culture
Page 142 of 423
142

tion and did not so much as stir. The general noticed him, and finding some excuse, passed in front of him a second time. Bediuzzaman still did not rise to his feet. So he passed by him a third time then stopped. He said to him through an interpreter:

"Do you not know who I am?"

"Yes, I know," replied Bediuzzaman, and told him.

"So why do you insult me?" asked the general.

"Forgive me, but I have not insulted you, I only did as my beliefs commanded me. "

"What do your beliefs command?"

"I am a Muslim scholar. There is faith in my heart. A person with faith is superior to a person without. If I had risen to my feet, it would have been disrespectful to my beliefs. Therefore, I did not."

"In which case, you are saying that I am without faith, and you are insulting both myself, and the army of which I am a member, and my nation, and the Czar. A court martial will be set up immediately, and you will be questioned."

A court martial was set up as the general decreed. The Turkish, German, and Austrian officers all came to the headquarters and tried to persuade Bediuzzaman to apologize to the general, but he told them:

"I am eager to travel to the realm of the Hereafter and enter the presence of God's Prophet, and I have to have a passport. I cannot act contrary to my beliefs."

Unable to dispute this reply, they awaited the court's verdict. The examination was completed. Then the decision was given for Bediuzzaman's execution on the grounds of insulting the Czar and the Russian Army.

When the squad arrived to carry out the sentence, Bediuzzaman requested fifteen minutes "to perform his duty." This was to take his ablutions and perform two rak'ahs of prayers. The Russian general arrived on the scene while Bediuzzaman was doing this. He suddenly realized his mistake and said to him when he had finished praying:

"Forgive me! I thought you behaved as you did in order to insult me and I acted accordingly. Now I realize you were merely acting as your beliefs required. Your sentence is quashed. You should be commended for your firmness of belief. Once again, I apologize." [^275]

[^275]:Abdürrahim Zapsu, in Ehl-i Sünnet Mecmuası, vol. 2, No. 46, 15 Teşrin-i Evvel (October) 1948, quoted in, Nursi, Şualar, 442-3 (Eng. tr.: Rays, 521); Şahiner, Said Nursi, 174-5; Tarihçe, 103-4.

Bediuzzaman mentioned this incident, which demonstrates his extraor-

4–6 October 2026 · Istanbul

13th International Bediuzzaman Symposium

Visit the symposium website for the programme, papers and registration.